‘Duck Dynasty’ Star Phil Robertson: What Are His Legal Options?
Friday, 20 December 2013
“Duck Dynasty” star Phil Robertson found himself out of a job on Wednesday — at least for the time being — when he was indefinitely suspended him from the hit A&E reality show, after he made several anti-gay remarks in a GQ interview.
It remains to be seen whether Robertson will be reinstated on the show — and it very well could turn out that, after a time-out session to let the controversy cool down, he could be back. But if the Robertson family patriarch doesn’t return to the show, does he have legal recourse against the network that airs the series?
*Also read:* ‘Duck Dynasty’: Inside the Decision to Suspend Phil Robertson (Exclusive)
While the specifics of Robertson’s agreement with A&E aren’t known, entertainment-industry protocol suggests that he would likely have have an uphill battle.
TheWrap spoke to multiple legal experts who said that, if Robertson’s contract contained a morals clause — as if often the case with on-air talent — than the reality TV star has little in the way of legal recourse.
*Also read:* ‘Duck Dynasty’ Fallout: GLAAD Reeling From Biggest Backlash in Years, Says Rep
Often, such morals clauses note that, if talents speaks or acts in a way that insults or denigrates people, the producer reserves the right to suspend or terminate that talent.
And typically, defining such language or actions is left to the discretion of the studio — basically, “if we say it is so, it is.” Tough to mount a legal argument against that.
*Also read:* ‘Duck Dynasty’: 5 Other Crazy Phil Robertson Quotes From the GQ Article
“My guess is that they [suspended Robertson] on the basis of a morality clause,” one entertainment attorney told TheWrap on Wednesday. “Once you sign a reality show contract, they own you.”
Entertainment attorney Neville Johnson also noted that talent agreements generally tend to favor the networks. “If you see these talent agreements, they basically say they can do everything except torture you,” Johnson said.
While some — notably, failed vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin — raised the issue of free speech in defense of Robertson, the “Duck Dynasty” star isn’t likely to find legal recourse under the banner of the First Amendment, as that only protects citizens from infringement on the government’s part.
*Also read:* ‘Duck Dynasty’: How Phil Robertson Became an Instant Conservative Martyr
“He has no First Amendment [complaint] against A&E,” Eugene Volokh, a professor at UCLA School of Law told TheWrap. “The First Amendment, the first word of the First Amendment is Congress: ‘Congress shall make no law.’”
And what of the possibility of arguing religious discrimination? While it’s true that Robertson’s anti-gay comments were couched in the context of Robertson’s religious beliefs, Volokh doesn’t see that as a likely success.
“It doesn’t sound like they were taking him off the show because they don’t like the fact that his message is religious; I think they don’t like the fact that his message is anti-gay,” Volokh said. “And people of various religions and no religions, some of them are anti-gay. and i imagine if an atheist on an A&E show said things that A&E thought disapproved of homosexuality, they would deal with it the same way.”
The post ‘Duck Dynasty’ Star Phil Robertson: What Are His Legal Options? appeared first on TheWrap.
*Related stories from TheWrap:*
'Duck Dynasty' Fallout: GLAAD Reeling From Biggest Backlash in Years, Says Rep
'Duck Dynasty': Inside the Decision to Suspend Phil Robertson (Exclusive)
Sean Hannity, 'Duck Dynasty' Fans Target A&E Executives as Phil Robertson Fallout Gets Personal
'Duck Dynasty': 5 Other Crazy Phil Robertson Quotes From the GQ Article
'Duck Dynasty': How Phil Robertson Became an Instant Conservative Martyr
Source: Newsy - on December 21, 2013|
Illinois Congressional candiate, Ian Bayne, compared "Duck Dynasty" star Phil Robertson to civil rights icon Rosa Parks.
Recent related news
What not to do at an Alan Davies stand-up show - turn up late...Cheltenham Town Hall: Alan DaviesBest known to some as the television star and dunderhead sidekick to Stephen Fry on the long-running QI series, Alan Davies has...
Gloucestershire Echo 19 hours ago - UK
NBC's ‘Constantine’ Boss Reveals Why Series Is Better Without Keanu Reeves and Lucy GriffithsKeanu Reeves won't reprise his film role on NBC's “Constantine,” but showrunner and executive producer Daniel Cerone thinks the supernatural horror series...
The Wrap 2 days ago - US
Pyaar Vali Love Story ReviewPyaar Vali Love Story Movie Poster
Rating: 2/5 Stars (Two stars)
Star Cast: Swapnil Joshi, Sai Tamhankar, Urmila Kanitkar, Upendra Limaye, Sameer...
Filmy Friday 2 days ago - Entertainment
Blake Griffin Laid The Hand Of God On Clubgoer, AllegedlyBlake Griffin allegedly slapped up a clubgoer in Las Vegas for taking his pic with a cellphone. The cops are investigating the allegations against the NBA...
Hip-Hop Wired 3 days ago - Entertainment
China furious after Kenny G appears to back Hong Kong protestersJazz saxophonist, who is huge in China, tweeted a picture of himself making a victory sign in front of a protest banner
Most governments arent too bothered by...
guardian.co.uk 4 days ago - UK
WHERE ARE THEY NOW? Here's What The Star Of 'The Adventures Of Pete & Pete' Is Doing TodayDanny Tamberelli ruled kids television in the 1990s. He's well known as Little Pete on Nickelodeon's "The Adventures of Pete & Pete" and was a cast member in...
Business Insider 4 days ago - Technology
Divergent’s Jai Courtney: ‘I wanted to punch Miles Teller for the first few weeks after I met him’We don’t know about you, but we were well surprised when Miles Teller let slip to Wonderland mag that he took the role in Divergent for “business reasons”,...
Sugarscape 5 days ago - Entertainment
Sophia Loren: how Cary Grant begged me to become his loverActresss letters reveal the Hollywood stars passionate pursuit of her while filming in Spain
When the young Sophia Loren dances a sultry flamenco in the role...
guardian.co.uk 1 week ago - Entertainment
You Might Like
Other recent news in US