Celebrating 10 Years of Trusted News Discovery
One News Page
> >

Cardinal Pell submits appeal to Australian High Court

CNA Tuesday, 17 September 2019
Melbourne, Australia, Sep 17, 2019 / 04:32 am (CNA).- Cardinal George Pell Tuesday submitted an application for leave to appeal his conviction to the Australian High Court, following the Aug. 21 decision by the Court of Appeal in Victoria to uphold his conviction for child sexual abuse.

The leave to appeal was filed in Melbourne by Pell's legal team Sept. 17, one day before the deadline of 28 days from the date of the Appeal Court decision.

Sources close to the cardinal told CNA Aug. 26 that Pell would be exercising his final appeal and that, while the majority of “special leave to appeal” cases were not granted by the High Court, his case would likely be accepted given the controversy triggered by the split decision of the Appeal Court judgement.

In seeking to take his case to the High Court in Canberra, Australia’s supreme court, Pell is exercising his last legal avenue to overturn a conviction which has divided opinion in the country and internationally.

Several Australian media outlets have reported that Pell will retain the same legal team which presented his case in Victoria, led by Brett Walker SC.

The cardinal was convicted Dec. 11, 2018, on five charges that he sexually abused two choristers after Sunday Mass while he was Archbishop of Melbourne in 1996 and 1997.

He was sentenced to six years in prison, of which he must serve at least three years and eight months before being eligible to apply for parole.

The cardinal, 78, who remains an archbishop and a member of the College of Cardinals, was returned to prison immediately after court adjourned, where he has remained. Pell has not been permitted to celebrate Mass in prison.

Pell’s appeal was presented on three grounds, two of which were procedural and dismissed by all three appeal judges.

The judges were divided on Pell’s primary ground of appeal, that the decision of the jury was “unreasonable.”

At particular issue was the question of whether the jury which convicted Pell had properly weighed all of the evidence presented in his defense, or reached the determination of guilt despite the demonstration of clear “reasonable doubt” that he committed the crimes with which he was charged.

Chief Justice Anne Ferguson and Court President Chris Maxwell formed the majority in favor of rejecting Pell’s appeal that the jury verdict was unreasonable on the evidence presented, finding that it was open to the jury to find beyond “reasonable doubt about the truth of the complainant's account.”

In an extensive dissent from the majority finding, Justice Mark Weinberg noted that the entirety of the evidence against Pell consisted of the testimony of a single accuser, whereas more than 20 witnesses were produced to testify against his narrative.

“Even the ‘reasonable possibility’ that what the witnesses who testified to these matters may have been true must inevitably have led to an acquittal,” Weinberg wrote, concluding that Pell had, in effect, been asked to establish the “impossibility” of his guilt and not merely reasonable doubt.

All three judges granted further leave to appeal on the ground of the unreasonableness of the jury’s conviction.

The decision by Pell to pursue the final legal avenue open to him means that a canonical process in Rome will be further delayed until the civil process concludes in Australia.
Credit: ODN - Published < > Embed
News video: Gina Miller arrives at Supreme Court for prorogation hearing

Gina Miller arrives at Supreme Court for prorogation hearing 00:51

Gina Miller arrives at the Supreme Court for the hearing into Boris Johnson's decision to suspend Parliament. The businesswoman brought an appeal after the High Court dismissed her case. Report by Barnesj. Like us on Facebook at and follow us on Twitter at...

Recent related videos from verified sources

Chris Williamson statement after losing legal challenge against the Labour Party [Video]Chris Williamson statement after losing legal challenge against the Labour Party

Suspended Labour MP Chris Williamson statement after losing his High Court bid to be reinstated to the party after he was suspended over allegations of anti-Semitism. Williamson calls for a..

Credit: PA - Press Association STUDIO     Duration: 01:32Published

High Court bans animal sacrifice in temples of Tripura [Video]High Court bans animal sacrifice in temples of Tripura

High Court bans animal sacrifice in temples of Tripura

Credit: ANI     Duration: 01:13Published

Recent related news from verified sources

Prosecutors urge Australian high court to ignore Pell appeal (The Age)

Australian prosecutors have urged the country’s top court not to accept an appeal by Cardinal George Pell of his conviction on abuse charges. The prosecutors...
Catholic Culture Also reported by •SBSReuters

High Court told to sound final bell on Pell

Victoria's prosecutors have urged Australia's highest court not to intervene in the case of George Pell.
The Age Also reported by •Zee News

You Might Like

Environmentally friendly: One News Page is hosted on servers powered solely by renewable energy
© 2019 One News Page Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
About us  |  Contact us  |  Disclaimer  |  Press Room  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Content Accreditation
 RSS  |  News for my Website  |  Free news search widget  |  In the News  |  DMCA / Content Removal  |  Privacy & Data Protection Policy
How are we doing? FeedbackSend us your feedback  |   LIKE us on Facebook   FOLLOW us on Twitter  •  FOLLOW us on Pinterest
One News® is a registered trademark of One News Page Ltd.