Global  

New Jersey Judge Says Movie Theater Chains Can’t Immediately Reopen

The Wrap Tuesday, 14 July 2020
New Jersey Judge Says Movie Theater Chains Can’t Immediately ReopenA New Jersey federal judge has denied a request from the major movie theater chains for a temporary restraining order against the state that would have allowed theaters to immediately reopen their doors.

The motion is a setback after companies like AMC, Regal and Cinemark and led by NATO jointly filed suit last week against New Jersey arguing that the state is violating the chains’ first amendment rights and taking property without just compensation.

Judge Brian R. Martinotti also set a hearing that’s expected for August 4 in which the theater chains’ request for an injunction will be litigated.

*Also Read:* Movie Theater Chains Sue New Jersey for 'Unconstitutional' Closures Due to Coronavirus

The lawsuit accused New Jersey of an “unconstitutional” practice by requiring movie theaters to remain closed due to the coronavirus while other indoor businesses, including and venues, including churches, museums, aquariums, libraries and public and private social clubs have been able to reopen beginning at the end of June through an executive order. The lawsuit named both governor Philip Murphy and the acting commissioner of health Judith Persichilli as defendants.

Martinotti wrote in his order that the plaintiffs failed to satisfy the “stringent standards for granting this extraordinary relief,” saying they had “ample opportunities” to file a request for a temporary restraining order between the governor’s initial executive order and their lawsuit.

“It is noteworthy that, as Plaintiffs file this application, states that initially ordered the re-opening of indoor movie theaters have once again ordered their closure in response to rising COVID-19 infection numbers,” the judge added.

*Also Read:* AMC Offers New Debt Agreement in Hopes of Surviving Coronavirus Shutdowns

Movie theaters have been closed since mid-March as a result of the coronavirus, and the chains argued in the lawsuit that though they’ve presented protocols for reopening and have shown a willingness to implement them, the defendants “Have provided no explanation for their disparate treatment of entities with similar risk levels regarding COVID-19, and none exists.”

The judge also directed the state to respond to the plaintiffs request for an injunction by July 24.

Pamela Chelin contributed to this report.

*Related stories from TheWrap:*

Newsom Orders Movie Theaters, Bars, Indoor Restaurants Closed Statewide

Why Movie Theater Chains Are Unlikely to Reopen Anytime Soon

Cinemark Gives Tour of Reopened Movie Theaters Under New Safety Guidelines (Video)
0
shares
ShareTweetSavePostSend
 

You Might Like


Related videos from verified sources

Suspect in New Jersey judge’s family attack linked to California killing [Video]

Suspect in New Jersey judge’s family attack linked to California killing

Federal investigators are examining whether a suspect in the ambush shooting of a federal judge’s family in New Jersey also killed a fellow men’s rights lawyer in California, a law enforcement..

Credit: KTLA     Duration: 00:44Published
Innovative Movie Theater Opening In Paris Resembles The Galactic Senate From Star Wars [Video]

Innovative Movie Theater Opening In Paris Resembles The Galactic Senate From Star Wars

This incredible new cinema opening in Paris resembles the galactic senate from Star Wars. The OMA cinema was designed by architect Pierre Chican. Its innovative design does away with traditional rows..

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO     Duration: 01:14Published
Search For Motive After Judge's Family Ambushed [Video]

Search For Motive After Judge's Family Ambushed

Extra security is in place for a New York State chief judge after there were indications she was targeted by the same man who attacked the family of a federal judge in New Jersey. CBS2's John Dias has..

Credit: CBS 2 New York     Duration: 02:45Published

Related news from verified sources

Movie Theater Chains Sue New Jersey for ‘Unconstitutional’ Closures Due to Coronavirus

Movie Theater Chains Sue New Jersey for ‘Unconstitutional’ Closures Due to Coronavirus
Major theater chains including AMC, Regal, Cinemark BJK Entertainment and Bow Tie Cinemas have sued the state of New Jersey, claiming it’s unconstitutional for...
The Wrap

Coronavirus updates: US nears 3M cases; Florida hospital ICUs reaching capacity; movie theater chains sue to reopen in New Jersey

The U.S. nears 3M cases; Hospitalizations spike in Florida; Movie theater chains file lawsuit to reopen in New Jersey. Latest coronavirus news
USATODAY.com


Tweets about this