Shay Mitchell plays 'Pretty Little Liars' game

Which "Pretty Little Liars" star would make the best babysitter?

Shay Mitchell — "You" actress and mom to 8-month-old Atlas — sat down with Page Six for a game of "Most Likely."

Who is most likely to teach Atlashow to tell a pretty, little lie?Ashley.(laughing)(low-key music)So first off, who ismost likely to babysit Atlas?Troian.Just because she has a child,but also, I mean, I would trust Lucy or Ashley as well,just because, you know, they're around kids quite often too.Me?Why?She's the rebel of the group?Yep.He knows we're lying.Lying is not a crime.Who is most likely to buy Atlas a really cute outfit?Lucy.Lucy is always like the best at gift giving for sure.But, Troian has brought Atlas a really cute outfitthat she's already worn.Is that true or is that not true?Who's most likely to make a TikTok video with you?Eh, I think any of the girls.I would just have to do it for them.But, probably, I mean Ashley.I've already done one with her, so yeah.Oh cute.♪ Wow, you can really dance ♪♪ Wow, you can really dance.

♪And lastly, who's most likely to bethe most OCD and super clean during quarantine?Yeah, yeah, I would say Troian, yeah.Does she have a little bit of Spencer in her?A little Type A?She has a little bit,but also she's just like so organized,and like you know, also having a child herself,she's like, you know, very cleanand has a very very healthy routine and all of that.So yeah, I would have to say Troian.I can't deal with this!(clattering)